"If JMU increases its supply of university managed housing, then demand for off-campus student housing, as we know, we would expect that to change," Thanh Dang, Harrisonburg's deputy director of community development, told City Council in August, according to The Breeze. "However, in staff's opinion, we felt that the change would be felt differently in different locations."
Anyone thinking about buying a townhouse, condo or small house in Harrisonburg to rent to James Madison University students should hold onto that second sentence. For about as long as anyone here can remember, the case for a student rental has rested on one assumption: JMU keeps growing, and most of its students live off campus. The university's new strategic plan keeps the first half of that and reverses the second. Once you work through JMU's own numbers, the question for a buyer stops being whether student demand is strong in Harrisonburg. It becomes where that demand will still be strong, and for how long.
The arithmetic inside the Madison Promise
JMU published the Madison Promise, its strategic plan, with a table of "guidepost" goals for 2032 and 2040. Two rows in that table matter to anyone who owns or is buying rental property near campus. Overall enrollment goes from a 2025 baseline of 23,157 students to 26,000 by 2032 and 30,000 by 2040. On-campus housing capacity goes from 28% in 2025 to 40% by 2032 and 60% by 2040.
If you read capacity as a share of total enrollment and multiply the two rows together, you get this:
| Year | Enrollment target | On-campus share | Students on campus | Students off campus |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 baseline | 23,157 | 28% | about 6,480 | about 16,670 |
| 2032 target | 26,000 | 40% | 10,400 | 15,600 |
| 2040 target | 30,000 | 60% | 18,000 | 12,000 |
Under JMU's targets, the university gains nearly 7,000 students by 2040, and about 4,670 fewer of them live off campus. City staff raised the Madison Promise with Council during the August debate over a downtown apartment building, The Breeze reported.
These are goals, not a forecast. JMU's enrollment planners told the Board of Visitors in September 2026 that "programs, buildings and beds determine when and where we can grow," and that the long-range enrollment plan will be developed by May 2027, when implementation begins. Still, a public university put these targets in writing, next to a priority initiative to build a mixed-use Madison District with new student housing, a stadium expansion and a third College of Business building. Your pro forma should account for them.
Timing matters more than the 2040 total
The decline is back-loaded. Between 2025 and 2032, the off-campus count falls by only about 1,070 students. Between 2032 and 2040, it falls by about 3,600. JMU's enrollment growth also speeds up late in the plan: the Board summary lays out three phases of about 1.5% a year for fiscal 2027 through 2031, 1.7% for fiscal 2032 through 2036, and 2.0% for fiscal 2037 through 2040. Most of the new on-campus beds the plan calls for arrive in the second half.
So two investors could buy the same Harrisonburg townhouse this winter and face very different markets. Someone planning to sell in five or six years owns through the gentle stretch of the table. Someone planning to hold for fifteen years owns through the steep stretch too, and will be selling into whatever off-campus demand looks like after it.
The present doesn't look like a turning point yet. JMU reported fall 2026 enrollment of 23,167, with a first-year class of 5,037, 1.1% above target. That is essentially level with the 2025 baseline of 23,157. The newest residence hall, Potomac Hall in the Village area, opened in 2025 with room for 458 residents. The larger projects on record are proposals. In August 2026, Maslow's Campus Communities proposed a 1,008-bed residence hall in Mid-Campus next to Bridgeforth Stadium, with occupancy targeted for fall 2029. Duke Dog Development Partners proposed 1,200-plus beds by 2028. Both were submitted as responses to JMU's procurement process.
Which students JMU is reaching for
JMU's housing policies already shape off-campus demand. The university requires first-year students to live in university residence halls, with listed exceptions. Second-year students can choose either, and JMU says it has space for about 30 to 35% of first-years who choose to stay a second year under its Live On Again! contract.
That suggests where the 28%-to-60% shift will be felt. First-years are already on campus, so any new capacity reaches upperclass students, starting with sophomores. Sophomores have long been the students moving into their first off-campus lease. For a landlord, the first-lease market is the one that refills a unit every August. If more sophomores stay on campus, the off-campus pool tilts toward juniors, seniors and graduate students. Those renters have more experience with leases and more opinions about where they want to live.
The city is approving beds at the same time
While JMU plans to house more of its own students, Harrisonburg keeps approving large privately built student projects. In July 2025, City Council approved Vista at Forest Hills at 810 Port Republic Road, a mixed-use plan for up to 119 apartments and 440 bedrooms on four apartment floors over parking, The Citizen reported. In August 2026, Council approved The Lindsey on a 3–2 vote. The project is on the Lindsey Funeral Home site at the entrance to downtown, between Main and Liberty streets. The developer, Timberwolf Capital Partners, cut the plan from six stories to four and from 550 bedrooms to a maximum of 180 units and 440 bedrooms, The Breeze reported. The Citizen's account also lists 320 parking spaces and 2,500 to 5,000 square feet of commercial space.
Off Port Republic Road, The Apartments at Peach Grove, a project by Skylar & Talli LLC of roughly 400 bedrooms, came back to Council with a request to turn ground-floor commercial space into about 60 more beds. City staff and the Planning Commission opposed the change. According to the Daily News-Record, staff said it did not believe more student housing was needed, and Councilman Chris Jones argued that new apartments could draw students out of other housing that families might then use. Council approved the change. On May 13, 2026, the Planning Commission recommended against a separate rezoning on Peach Grove Avenue.
Approval and construction run on different clocks. A city official told the Daily News-Record that approvals don't guarantee a project gets built. Even so, Vista and The Lindsey alone are approved for 880 bedrooms, and each new private building competes for the same upperclass renters JMU wants to bring back on campus.
Location is the variable
For a buyer, where a property sits now carries more weight than citywide student demand. Purpose-built complexes have amenities, shuttle access and leasing offices. JMU's new beds will sit inside the Madison District. An older townhouse or a converted house is a different product competing for a smaller pool of upperclass renters. How it holds up likely depends on what is within walking distance of it, and on whether its next buyer could be someone who isn't a landlord at all.
The developers' side of the Council debate made a location argument too. The Lindsey's representative, land-use attorney Todd Rhea, said the building would put "almost 500 new residents of any type within walking distance of downtown businesses," according to The Breeze. A building that size changes who lives within a few blocks of it, and that is as true for the houses around Port Republic Road as for the downtown lot.
Financing matters more than usual this year. Freddie Mac's average 30-year fixed rate was 7.11% for the week of November 12, 2026. Statewide, Virginia REALTORS® reported pending sales in the third quarter of 2026 down 7.3% from a year earlier. A buyer can be more selective in a slower market, and a student rental is a purchase where being selective pays.
Questions buyers are asking
Does this mean student rentals in Harrisonburg are a bad investment? No. JMU's own targets keep about 15,600 students living off campus in 2032 and 12,000 in 2040, so off-campus demand doesn't disappear. The off-campus pool gets smaller and older over time, and properties near campus will have more competition for those renters.
What should I look at first on a specific property? Start with where it sits relative to campus, the Madison District, the approved Port Republic Road projects and downtown. Then ask who would buy it from you if it were never a rental again. A property that works for a household that isn't a landlord gives you a second exit.
When will the on-campus beds actually open? JMU's targets are 2032 and 2040. The largest residence hall proposals were submitted to JMU in August 2026 with occupancy dates of 2028 and fall 2029, and the enrollment plan behind them is scheduled for May 2027.
This post is general market information, not financial or tax advice. Please confirm the numbers for your own situation with your lender and tax professional.
If you're weighing a rental near JMU, or deciding whether to hold or sell one you already own, I'm glad to walk the property with you and go through how it fits these numbers. Mary Beth Harris and Bluebird Construction & Design can also help you figure out what it would take to make the house appeal to the next kind of buyer. Let me help you find a house and create a home.