Warm oak residential door recessed in weathered red brick, above worn limestone steps and a narrow concrete sidewalk.

Who Moved Into Downtown Harrisonburg's Empty Kitchens This Year

In early September, the special at the new restaurant on Liberty Street was a Peach Mousse Cake made to look exactly like a peach. The shell was blushed white chocolate. Inside were vanilla-tarragon mousse and peach-amaretto compote. Taylor Cosby made it, and she wasn't new to the room. She had managed Mashita in that same space. When Mashita closed and Elephant Head opened there, she stayed on as general manager and brought her pastry work with her, as The Harrisonburg Citizen reported in its October food column.

That one dessert sums up downtown Harrisonburg's year. Five familiar places closed in 2026: the Golden Pony, Friendly City Fermenter, Three Notch'd Brewery, Sweet & Tasty, and Mashita. Most of what replaced them came from the same small group of cooks, owners and staff, moving from one room to the next. People who knew these places last spring will recognize a lot of who is cooking now.

One closing on Liberty Street, three kitchens reshuffled

Mikey Reisenberg announced in February that Mashita would close after more than six years on Liberty Street. That one decision set off a chain.

Colin Auckerman took the space for Elephant Head. He grew up in Rockingham County and spent the past decade running the kitchens at Bella Luna Wood-Fired Pizza and The Local Chop & Grill House. Elephant Head is the first restaurant that is entirely his. The menu is shareable new American plates made with Mediterranean techniques and what he calls "a good amount of Silk Road influences," such as Chinese five-spice in a Butternut & Duck Confit Soup. The menu changes constantly, and much of the produce comes from Wayside Produce, Seasons Bounty Farm, and Friendly Neighbor Gardens. "What grows together, goes together," Auckerman told The Citizen.

His move left the top job open at Bella Luna. In March, owner Wade Luhn texted Beau Floyd, who had been Auckerman's sous chef when Bella Luna first fired its ovens in 2013. Floyd had stepped away from restaurant kitchens for about four and a half years after running Food.Bar.Food with his wife, Amanda, and serving as executive chef at Hotel Madison's Montpelier Restaurant and Bar. Now he runs Bella Luna's kitchen. He is training a sous chef of his own, Andy Wu, who spent 13 years at Wayside Produce.

The Citizen's columnist summed up the chain this way: "Mikey Reisenberg's decision to close Mashita opened a door for Auckerman, which opened one for Floyd."

Hours as listed in that October column: Elephant Head serves dinner nightly from 4 to 10 p.m. and Sunday brunch from 10:30 a.m. to 2 p.m. Bella Luna opens daily at 11:30 a.m. and closes at 8:30 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and 9:30 p.m. Friday and Saturday.

Why the rooms didn't stay dark

The Liberty Street chain happened because people wanted that space. Harrisonburg Downtown Renaissance's numbers back this up. In The Citizen's August look at the turnover, the organization's data showed that 2026 had the most downtown restaurant closures since 2016. It was also tied for the most openings.

Executive director Andrea Dono described something new about how the spaces changed hands:

"This is the first year that I've heard multiple offers made on spaces where the business owner announced a closing and had not yet vacated the space. I think this reflects pent-up demand given that we started the year with the lowest vacancy rate downtown has seen since revitalization began."

She also pointed out that some downtown spaces end up holding more businesses than before. The former Capitol Waffle Shop and Posh Fairy Floss spaces were combined into Outsider Gear Exchange. When the Daily News-Record downsized, its building took in Illyeria, a Mediterranean restaurant, along with an apartment and a showroom for Lauf Cycles. "A building that housed one business turned into a space that housed 3 businesses and one apartment," Dono said.

Pierce Macgill, the city's assistant director of economic development, said this year's closings stood out mostly because "they're kind of close together and recognizable."

The new tenants, address by address

Here is where the year's openings landed, using the addresses from local reporting and the city's economic development office.

Address Before Now
Liberty Street Mashita Elephant Head, new American with Mediterranean and Silk Road influences
241 E. Market St. Three Notch'd Brewery Two Jays Kitchen and Bar, Filipino favorites, Latin American-inspired dishes and American classics
140 E. Wolfe St. Gamer Oasis Wizard Mode Brewcade, an arcade and bar
1007 S. Main St. Tequila Taco Bar Taaza, Indian cuisine
412 S. Main St. Joshua Wilton House dining room Table 1888, French-American
66 E. Market St. Retail space Turkish Art and Cafe

Several of these follow the same pattern as Liberty Street.

Table 1888 opened Aug. 13 inside the Victorian-era Joshua Wilton House. Ethan Herman, a Shenandoah Valley native, runs it with his parents and business partners, Amy and Lester Herman. The executive chef, Tom French, has been part of the Joshua Wilton House since 2009, so the kitchen is familiar even though the concept is new. Rocktown Now reported a 180-bottle wine list with Virginia wineries and labels from more than 20 countries. Renovations restored the original parquet floors. The five-room boutique hotel upstairs stays open. Dinner runs Thursday through Monday from 4:30 to 8:30 p.m., and brunch runs Friday through Sunday from 9:30 a.m. to 2 p.m. The restaurant planned to add a late-night bar menu until 1 a.m. on Fridays and Saturdays starting in September. Reservations are at table1888.com.

Taaza opened Aug. 14 across from JMU's campus. Owner Nirav Savaj told The Breeze that the menu includes Indian dishes with Chinese and American influences. Local sources don't agree on the name, so you may see it as Taaza 2.0 Indian Cuisine, Taaza Bistro, or Taaza Indian Cuisine.

Two Jays Kitchen and Bar took over the former Three Notch'd room on Market Street. It was pouring a pumpkin espresso martini and serving lumpia cups at Harrisonburg Downtown Renaissance's Skeleton Festival Sip & Stroll on Oct. 24.

Turkish Art and Cafe got here first, opening on June 2 at 66 E. Market St.

On Wolfe Street, the Golden Pony's staff found work

The Golden Pony closed in June after 11 years as a home for Harrisonburg's music scene. Owner Paul Somers said at the time, "Small independent music venues are truly endangered right now, and we are an unfortunate example of that."

Part of what the Golden Pony offered moved to Wolfe Street. Wizard Mode Brewcade sits between Kline's Dairy Bar and the Friendly City Co-op. It comes from Moon, who also owns Restless Moons Brewing. He told The Citizen that his staff includes people hired from recently closed venues like the Golden Pony. He also plans open mics, karaoke and live music shows. "I would never say that we will be able to fill the void that's been left by those venues, but we're going to do the best that we can to bring live music to the community," Moon said.

The arcade machines take quarters and don't pay out tickets. Collectibles, merchandise and snacks from around the world are for sale instead. The bar serves sodas, nonalcoholic drinks, and beer brewed at Restless Moons. General manager Davis Cabrera called it "a place where you can come and let go, be a kid again and enjoy being together with friends." Visit Harrisonburg also lists pinball, trading-card and board games, and Dungeons & Dragons. Food is limited, and the Daily News-Record reported that you can bring your own. Wizard Mode poured its Dortmunder Lager and Oktoberfest at the Oct. 24 Sip & Stroll.

The rooms that haven't turned over yet

Not every space has a new tenant. No one has announced a successor for the Golden Pony, Friendly City Fermenter, or Sweet & Tasty locations. When Friendly City Fermenter closed after nearly nine years, owner Shawn Gatesman said, "Foot traffic changed tremendously."

Sarah Baker-McEvilly of BMC Bakes told The Citizen that her customer count has held steady but people spend less per visit. She added that summer foot traffic drops when many college students go home. "Downtown is not as busy as it needs to be to support as many businesses as there are," she said.

Dates for a first visit, November into December

Several upcoming downtown events put these new places within walking distance:

  • Saturday, Nov. 7: Harvest Fest at the Harrisonburg Farmers Market, 8 a.m. to 1 p.m.
  • Saturdays Nov. 14, 21 and 28: fall Saturday markets, generally 8 a.m. to 1 p.m., plus Tuesday markets on Nov. 10, 17 and 24.
  • Fridays Nov. 6 and Dec. 4: First Fridays at City Hall, 409 S. Main St., 5 to 7 p.m. City Hall is a short walk from Table 1888 at 412 S. Main.
  • Saturdays Dec. 5 and 12: Holiday Markets at the farmers market, 9 a.m. to 1 p.m.
  • Saturday, Dec. 5: Winter Wonderfest downtown. The Holiday Parade is part of it and starts at 7 p.m. at the Rockingham County Office Building on Gay Street, heads south on Main Street to City Hall, and ends with a tree lighting in Court Square.

The parade ends at City Hall, 409 S. Main St. Table 1888 is at 412 S. Main St.

Downtown spaces that changed hands this year got new owners, new menus, and in Table 1888's case, a restored historic interior. If you own a home near downtown and want to talk about what a refresh before listing could look like, Mary Beth Harris and Bluebird Construction & Design can walk through it with you, room by room.

Guided Every Step of the Way

From staging to closing, expect honest guidance, open communication, and a smooth, stress-free experience.

Follow Me on Instagram